The Paris Métro problem is real and underestimated. Maps downloaded offline help, but Google Maps' live navigation updates routing in real time as delays happen — and RATP (the Paris transit operator) regularly diverts trains, closes stations for maintenance, and runs reduced weekend schedules that offline maps won't reflect. Citymapper handles Paris better than most navigation apps and is worth downloading before you go, but it needs a data connection to show live departure times and platform changes. Beyond navigation, the practical Paris list: unlocking Airbnb keypads requires SMS or app confirmation (a quick data connection), most museum and attraction ticket systems now push QR codes via email rather than printing them (useful when you're standing in the queue at the Louvre with 800 other people), and ride-sharing via Uber or Bolt needs live GPS to match you with a driver. The Paris Vélib' bike-sharing app works on live data. None of this is catastrophic without data, but each friction adds up across a week-long trip.
Outside Paris, the regional realities diverge. Provence and the Côte d'Azur are well-served — Nice, Cannes, Aix-en-Provence, and the villages of the Luberon have reliable coverage for navigating cliff-edge roads, finding restaurant parking, and making restaurant reservations via TheFork. The D-road network through the Dordogne and Périgord Noir — where many travellers self-drive between medieval castles and prehistoric caves — has stretches of poor coverage in the deeper river valleys. Download offline maps for any self-driving in the southwest before leaving town. Brittany's coastline is better served than its inland areas; the Cap Finistère and Presqu'île de Crozon peninsulas have reasonable coverage at the coast but gaps on the minor roads inland. Lyon is a genuinely well-connected city with Metro signal at many stations — a meaningful contrast with Paris — and the Rhône-Alpes region generally has solid urban and periurban coverage.
Mountain areas follow a predictable pattern: resort centres work, backcountry doesn't. Chamonix town has strong coverage; the Aiguille du Midi cable car loses signal above the mid-station. Les Deux Alpes and Val d'Isère have coverage in the villages and at major lift stations, but ski runs on north-facing slopes and backcountry zones go offline. The same applies in the Pyrenees — Pau and Lourdes have good coverage, Gavarnie and the high cirques do not. If you're hiking in the Pyrenees National Park or the Écrins massif, treat mobile data as a bonus rather than a primary navigation tool; carry paper maps or a dedicated GPS device. The Canal du Midi corridor between Toulouse and Sète is well-covered for barge holidays and cycle touring. Corsica has improved considerably — Ajaccio, Bonifacio, and the coast road have usable 4G, but the mountainous Haute-Corse interior (the GR20 hiking route) has real coverage gaps, especially above the tree line.